Skip to content

Grand Jury Declines Charges in Nolan Wells’ Mysterious Death

Lucas James Taylor 0 8 min read
Share

A grand jury has concluded that there is insufficient evidence to bring charges related to the death of Nolan Wells, a Black college student whose remains were discovered following a boating excursion and celebration on an island near the Mississippi Gulf Coast on July 4. Wells’s family quickly expressed their disagreement with the jury’s findings.

District Attorney Angel Myers McIlrath, who has been in charge of the inquiry into the 18-year-old’s death, revealed the grand jury’s conclusions late on Monday after months of speculation regarding the circumstances of Wells’s disappearance from the lively gathering and the decision by his friends to leave Horn Island without him.

The grand jury indicated that no criminal behavior was detected and stated that various factors, including the condition and location of Wells’s body when it was discovered two days after he was last seen, suggested his death was “consistent with drowning.” While the state medical examiner’s autopsy findings are not publicly available, the grand jury report indicated that both this autopsy and a separate one conducted by a forensic pathologist hired by Wells’s family identified bruising on the back of his head, though the exact cause of death remained undetermined.

At a press conference on Tuesday, Wells’s mother, Christine Wonsley, expressed confusion over how the grand jury could determine that her son drowned accidentally in light of the autopsy findings.

“How can a jury conclude drowning, knowing there was trauma to his body and hearing numerous inconsistencies?” she questioned.

Lawyers representing Wells’s friends, who have faced online speculation and accusations, welcomed the grand jury’s findings, with one attorney stating that his client can now begin to grieve properly.

During its investigation into potential criminal activity, the grand jury issued 132 subpoenas and heard from 43 witnesses through direct testimony, sworn statements, and recorded interviews, as detailed in the report. It considered various forms of evidence, including cell phone records, forensic analyses, videos, and GPS data.

A woman clings onto the shoulder of a man as he speaks into a microphone at a podium.

Nolan Wells’s father, Elmore Wonsley, speaks at a news conference in Stonecrest, Ga., on Tuesday, accompanied by Wells’s mother, Christine Wonsley, following the grand jury’s decision. (Emilie Megnien/The Associated Press)

Attorneys for Wells’s family, including civil rights lawyer Ben Crump, stated that the grand jury’s report raises more questions than it answers and accused the district attorney of concluding the investigation without clarifying the source of the blunt force trauma found on Wells’s head and body.

“Before declaring a death as drowning, all other possible causes must be eliminated,” Crump remarked during the news conference, where his team unveiled the complete independent autopsy report. “What other cause did the district attorney neglect to rule out? Blunt force trauma… Common sense indicates that this young man did not simply drown.”

Renewed request for DOJ independent investigation

One witness testified to the grand jury that he observed Wells awkwardly fall off the side of a boat around 3:30 p.m. on July 4, but noted that Wells continued to socialize after the incident without showing signs of injury, according to the report. The panel was unable to determine if the fall was responsible for the bruising on Wells’s body.

Wonsley stated that she learned of the grand jury’s findings only moments before McIlrath shared a video about them on her office’s Facebook page, which she felt lacked compassion.

“Last night served as a painful reminder that our son’s life holds no significance to those in power who are meant to protect and serve the public,” Wonsley said, fighting back tears. “Nolan is loved. He is valued. He is honored. And he did not deserve to have his life taken away so abruptly.”

Crump and others reaffirmed their request on Tuesday for the U.S. Department of Justice to launch an independent investigation, and urged McIlrath to disclose the investigation files along with the full autopsy report from the state medical examiner. Kristen Clarke, the NAACP’s general counsel and a former head of the DOJ’s Civil Rights Division, emphasized the rationale for the Justice Department to initiate an investigation, considering that the island is a federally managed and patrolled location.

This case has ignited widespread speculation and skepticism as individuals reflect on Mississippi’s complex racial history and the implications of being a Black person in a predominantly white environment. All other individuals who traveled with Wells to the island were white.

During Wells’s funeral, civil rights leader Rev. Al Sharpton highlighted the state’s history of racism in his eulogy, referencing events such as the lynching of Emmett Till and the assassination of Medgar Evers.

“Mississippi’s past painfully illustrates why families should never be expected to simply accept unresolved questions surrounding the death of a young Black individual,” Sharpton stated on Tuesday. “Transparency and accountability are essential. The truth is vital. Nolan’s life was significant.”

Shortly after Wells was discovered deceased, officials from the Jackson County sheriff’s department indicated that they did not suspect foul play, raising significant concerns regarding the thoroughness of the investigation by law enforcement. McIlrath consistently assured a fair and comprehensive investigation into his death.

DA expresses frustration over ‘false narratives’

In a 15-minute video presenting the grand jury’s findings, McIlrath expressed her frustration over the inaccurate speculations surrounding Wells’s fate. She also noted that attorneys for Wells’s family had informed her office the previous month that their own investigation revealed no evidence of criminal actions.

“What I cannot accept, what I cannot overlook, is the perpetuation of false narratives suggesting that Nolan’s death was racially motivated, and that this is yet another case of a young Black man denied justice by a corrupt, racist system. There is not a shred of evidence to support these claims,” she stated.

Attorneys representing three of Wells’s friends, who have been subjected to unfounded and widespread online rumors alleging their involvement in his death, reported that the grand jury’s findings offer relief to their clients.

“One of my client’s comments was that he felt he could finally breathe for the first time,” attorney Tyler Cox relayed regarding one of Wells’s friends. “This does not bring Nolan back, but it at least allows them to begin to mourn Nolan now that they have been officially exonerated of any wrongdoing.”

A woman holds a sign as she stands next to others.

The deaths of Nolan Wells, Daniel Erving and Tyler Smith have become the focus of national attention and advocacy, as seen at the National Urban League’s annual conference in Nashville on July 30. (John Amis/The Associated Press)

Wells’s family and their attorneys expressed doubts regarding the circumstances under which Wells’s friends departed the island without him, claiming he intended to stay behind and converse with a girl. His phone remained on the boat that transported him to the island, which was later partially towed back to the mainland after taking on water.

Crump and Wells’s parents questioned why a teenager would choose to remain on an island without his cell phone. They also raised concerns that messages on his phone may have been altered and claimed that his friends hesitated to surrender his phone and keys.

The grand jury received a report from experts consulted by Crump regarding the contents of Wells’s phone, although specific details were not disclosed in the grand jury’s redacted report.

The grand jury found that it was not uncommon or suspicious for individuals to return from the island on boats that were different from the ones they initially arrived on, as indicated in the report. It also noted that Wells’s phone was not the only one that returned to the mainland without its owner that day.

Furthermore, the report stated that even though alcohol was detected in Wells’s system, the results were deemed highly unreliable since the testing involved decompositional fluid. Such fluid analyzed post-mortem may contain alcohol consumed during life as well as ethanol created after death through microbial fermentation, it explained.

The grand jury report concluded by expressing sympathy for Wells’s family, stating, “The evidence presented to us confirmed Mr. Wells’s exemplary character.”

Share

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *