As Yogi Berra famously said, “It ain’t over till it’s over” — a phrase that brings a glimmer of hope to Blue Jays fans as Toronto embarks on a late-season pursuit of a playoff berth.
This 2026 season has been challenging for Toronto, as the defending American League (AL) champions have faced injuries and displayed erratic performance on the field. The team has struggled to meet expectations, maintaining a losing record for much of the year, including currently.
Nevertheless, the Blue Jays remain, astonishingly, in contention for a playoff position.
Toronto is set to kick off a three-game series in Cleveland on Tuesday, providing the team with an opportunity to advance in the standings at a crucial juncture.
“You have a chance to leave Cleveland with a playoff spot,” emphasized Sho Alli, a host at Sportsnet 590 The Fan, highlighting the significance of the upcoming three games.
Here’s how the Blue Jays have managed to stay in the race for a postseason spot.
Aiming for a Wild Card
The current playoff format in Major League Baseball allows 12 teams to qualify for the playoffs each year — six from the AL and six from the National League.
The six postseason teams in each league consist of three division winners and three additional wild cards — the teams with the highest overall records not among the division champions.
The Blue Jays are part of the AL East division, which is currently led by the Tampa Bay Rays, followed by the New York Yankees and the Boston Red Sox.
If the season were to conclude today, the Rays would secure a playoff position as division champions, while the Yankees and Red Sox, with the next best records in the AL, would occupy two of the three wild-card spots, respectively.
The Cleveland Guardians are currently leading the race for the third wild-card position.
Seeking to Climb
Along with Toronto, the Baltimore Orioles, Texas Rangers, Minnesota Twins, and Seattle Mariners are all within five games of Cleveland. All are competing for that same wild-card slot, even though they are predominantly struggling in the standings.
“It’s somewhat astonishing how poorly the American League has performed,” remarked Bob Nightengale, a columnist for USA Today, who believes it’s unusual for sub-.500 teams to be in contention for the postseason.

Ernie Clement, Myles Straw, Andrés Giménez, and Brett Bateman celebrate Toronto’s victory over Seattle at Rogers Centre on Saturday. (Jon Blacker/The Canadian Press)
The Jays are at least showing improvement lately, having played solid baseball in August with a record of 17-11, raising their overall season record to 68-70 ahead of Tuesday’s matchup.
In contrast, the Guardians finished August with a 13-13 record, bringing their overall record to 69-68 heading into the series against Toronto.
-
Buck Martinez inducted into Blue Jays’ new Hall of Excellence at Rogers Centre
-
Max Scherzer moves into 9th on career strikeout list with 10 Ks in vintage performance
Cleveland was tied for the third wild-card position at the start of August but now sits slightly ahead of Baltimore (69-69 after Monday’s matches) and Toronto.
Randy Robles from Elias Sports Bureau mentioned to CBC News that the Guardians had a slightly worse record of 68-69 at this time last year but managed to win the American League’s Central division.
Alli noted that the current Cleveland squad possesses a formidable starting rotation, including Gavin Williams — a pitcher known for one of the highest strikeout totals in the majors, who is expected to start Tuesday’s game against Toronto.
He also pointed out the Canadian closer Cade Smith, who poses a challenge if the Blue Jays encounter him on the mound in a game’s closing moments.
Nightengale highlighted that the Guardians are committed to competing for a postseason opportunity, having made trades at the deadline to acquire outfielder Jo Adell and pitcher Foster Griffin, among others, to strengthen their roster.
However, he emphasized that the Jays face a broader competition as they attempt to rise in the standings.
“Don’t forget that Baltimore is in the mix as well.”
The Jays and Orioles are scheduled to meet in another three-game series later this month.
Toronto will also have a September series against the Rangers, who matched the Blue Jays in the standings on Monday night.
Maintaining Pitching Strength
This year, Toronto’s starting pitching depth has diminished due to injuries impacting several pitchers, including Shane Bieber and Trey Yesavage.
Currently, the Blue Jays are relying on ace Dylan Cease, newly acquired José Soriano, and veteran Max Scherzer to keep the team competitive. The rest of the rotation remains uncertain due to injuries affecting the pitching staff.

Blue Jays starter Max Scherzer delivers a pitch during Sunday’s game against the Mariners. Scherzer achieved his strongest performance of the season, striking out 10 batters over seven innings. (Jon Blacker/The Canadian Press)
Cease is vying for a Cy Young Award and has been exceptional on the mound this season. Soriano has shown promise during his brief time with the Jays, while Scherzer has been heating up throughout August.
Recent addition Spencer Arrighetti, who has struggled in his initial starts with Toronto, had been expected to be the starter for the series opener against the Guardians. However, prior to Tuesday’s matchup, the team altered its plans, opting for rookie Spencer Miles to take the mound instead.
According to Sportsnet, Arrighetti may still pitch later in the game.
Cease and Soriano are also slated to start against Cleveland later in the series.
Toronto will depend on a bullpen led by Louis Varland to ensure close games do not slip away against the Guardians.
Flickering Power or Signs of Revival?
This season, the Blue Jays have struggled with power hitting, ranking near the bottom of the league in home runs.
However, some of the Jays’ batters have begun to hit home runs more consistently in recent outings.

Blue Jays outfielder Nathan Lukes connects for a home run against the New York Yankees during an August 22 contest at Yankee Stadium. (Jim McIsaac/Getty Images)
Nathan Lukes hit five home runs in August (four in his last nine games), as did catcher Alejandro Kirk. Power hitter George Springer contributed two home runs, both coming in consecutive games at the end of the month.
Franchise player Vladimir Guerrero Jr. has faced challenges this season, tallying only seven home runs. Nonetheless, a ball he struck at 116 miles per hour over the weekend indicates that his power remains intact, even if his home run count is below his expectations.
A continued increase in power could significantly benefit a Blue Jays team that has also struggled to score runs, ranking among the lowest in the league this year.





