You are Johnny Depp. Your professional life, built largely on the goodwill and affection associated with your name, or more specifically, Captain Jack Sparrow’s, has been significantly damaged.
A chaotic and highly publicized series of allegations regarding on-set assaults (including a lawsuit you resolved) and domestic abuse (which you have contested), coupled with high-profile defamation trials, have collectively damaged your previously pristine reputation. Your last significant role in a franchise, portraying Gellert Grindelwald in the Fantastic Beasts series of the Harry Potter universe, concluded when Warner Bros. requested your resignation following your loss in a libel case against the Sun newspaper for labeling you a “wife beater.”
Since then, your appearances have been scarce. In the meantime, years of extravagant spending led you to acquire a private island and an entire French village (as well as an amount of wine sufficient to intoxicate the entirety of the country) and to accumulate debts rivaling those of some of the most lavishly spending small nations.
What is your next move?
Interestingly, for your first significant Hollywood role after concluding your defamation case against ex-partner Amber Heard (a trial you mostly won, resulting in Heard being ordered to pay you $10 million US for her abuse claims), you have opted for Ebenezer. A cherished yet perennially retold tale. To some, this decision may seem more like a publicity stunt than a genuinely entertaining film.
On further reflection, remaking Charles Dickens’s A Christmas Carol could actually hold some validity. The narrative follows the stingy Scrooge as he learns to embrace Christmas and humanity through encounters with one ghost and three spirits, set in Victorian England. You once again have the opportunity to navigate the grimy streets of London, utilizing that accent that Americans find convincing but Brits find unsettling that you’ve developed throughout your career.
However, as you stride confidently in your meticulously worn cloaks and period-appropriate quirky hats, it may be challenging for viewers to maintain the fondness they once felt for your performances in Edward Scissorhands, Sweeney Todd, or even Charlie and the Chocolate Factory‘s Willy Wonka — in your previous modern reimagining. They used to appreciate you, didn’t they?
This seemingly adequate return feels reminiscent of that sentiment. Is it possible for them to embrace you once more?
-
REVIEW
Apple TV’s Nocturne is Nordic noir by the numbers
-
REVIEW
Wild Horse Nine is a bleak, hopeless sign of the times. You’re going to love it
In truth, this isn’t a poor performance. Your wide-eyed expressions and sentimental soliloquies guide audiences through Dickens’s timeless yet somewhat cloying narrative of transformation from bitterness to redemption.
This does not showcase a groundbreaking Depp performance, nor is it particularly profound or innovative. Yet, it resembles the works you used to deliver. The unique smirk and casually amusing dialogue that supported blockbuster films still remain. That surely holds some value, doesn’t it?
Furthermore, you are joined by a stellar cast, featuring Ian McKellen as your cautionary tale colleague Jacob Marley, Rupert Grint as your overworked and undervalued assistant Bob Cratchit, and Tramell Tillman portraying the ominous, pagan-like Ghost of Christmas Present.

Tramell Tillman, left, plays the Ghost of Christmas Present to Johnny Depp’s Ebenezer Scrooge in Ebenezer. (Jaap Buitendijk/Paramount Pictures)
Each of them fulfills their role: delivering exaggerated lines from effectively archetypical — and deliberately simplistic — characters. Their goal is to ensure your unlikable protagonist endures enough suffering to ultimately emerge as sympathetic and deserving of reintegration into society.
In fact, the familiarity and Depp-typical nature of it all leaves audiences half-expecting to see Helena Bonham Carter’s face appear from around every shadowy, cobbled corner. Director Ti West (MaXXXine, Pearl, X) attempts to impart his signature campy-horror twist to the original material, but rather than the intriguing genre fusion seen in Tim Burton’s Scissorhands, the end result resembles more of a daytime play.
The film includes jarring sounds of rattling chains and wailing ghosts that feel like they could have come from any typical casting call. West’s few inventive takes appear to aim for humor, yet come off as clumsily direct. For instance, instead of Dickens’s trembling specters symbolizing “ignorance” and “want,” we see creatures reminiscent of Dr. Seuss’s Thing 1 and Thing 2, screeching and scampering around like tiny, transparent ankle-biters from the netherworld.
Redemption roulette
So what was your motivation, Johnny? If you consider it, relying on this now overused narrative instead of seeking something new is ideal for your current situation. You are far from the first celebrity to experience “fall from grace” headlines. In that seemingly endless list of efforts to reclaim your status, a common thread tends to emerge.
There are multiple unsuccessful attempts. Like Will Smith’s painfully self-critical Emancipation, centered on a man who was so brutally beaten that images of his whip-scarred back contributed to the abolition of slavery. Or Kevin Spacey’s amateurish The Man Who Drew God, depicting a blind man wrongfully accused of child abuse. Additionally, there are Armie Hammer’s Citizen Vigilante and Jonathan Majors’s Run Hide Fight: Infidels — each portraying a solitary man fiercely combating figures the films depict as malevolent.
Conversely, there are successful comebacks. Winona Ryder made her way back from a criminal conviction with a minor role in Black Swan, but her true re-entry into the limelight was as the endlessly self-sacrificing and reliable mother in Stranger Things. After gaining a reputation for poor performances both on set and at the box office, Mickey Rourke made a (temporarily) remarkable return as the beaten and broken yet valiant protagonist in The Wrestler.
-
REVIEW
Will Smith’s comeback, Emancipation, reduces a slave narrative to an action film
-
REVIEW
Tom Cruise is fantastic in Digger. You might hate it
Robert Downey Jr. perhaps achieved the most remarkable comeback in history, transforming the public’s perception of his struggles with substance abuse and arrests into a heroic billionaire altruist in Iron Man.
Of course, the quality of a film does not correlate with whether a star is a good person. While not a universal truth, the pattern for recovery tends to be reliable: If you want to mend a reputation following controversy, depict yourself as the pitiable victim or self-sacrificing hero (or both) in a narrative that subtly reflects your own experiences.
Though Ebenezer may be perfectly adequate — and as imaginative as the entry on “Simple Wikipedia” — it certainly serves your interests. Based on a tale so effective at engendering goodwill towards humanity that it essentially defined the contemporary concept of Christmas generosity, what more could you desire?




