Skip to content

Montreal Police Under Fire: 16 Officers Investigated for Racist Acts

Lucas James Taylor 0 8 min read
Share

On June 12, Chief Fady Dagher of the Montreal police held a news conference late at night to disclose that 16 officers from the same precinct are being investigated for racist and hateful actions against Black and Arab communities.

This controversy has heightened scrutiny on the Montreal police, as Dagher disclosed that the accusations involve officers cutting pieces of locs from individuals’ hair and keeping them as trophies.

Charmaine Nelson, a provost professor of art history and the founding director of the Slavery North Initiative at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, characterized these alleged actions as “a complete and utter horrific affront to us in terms of our bodily integrity.”

In discussions with CBC, both Nelson and historian Aly Ndiaye remarked that this racist behavior is rooted in the legacy of the transatlantic slave trade, which includes both Canada and Quebec, and they examined how this history has influenced contemporary law enforcement practices.

SPVM Station 39 in Montréal-Nord

Sixteen officers from the Montreal police station 39 in the borough of Montréal-Nord are under investigation. (Kwabena Oduro/CBC)

Ndiaye, who is also known as Webster in the Quebec hip-hop scene, is an independent historian and the founder of Qc History X, a guided tour in Quebec City that explores the history of people of African descent and slavery.

Alongside her work at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, Nelson also serves as the founder and CEO of Black Maple Magazine and is originally from Montreal.

These interviews were conducted separately and have been edited for length and clarity.


Charmaine Nelson

Charmaine Nelson, the founding director of the Slavery North Initiative at University of Massachusetts Amherst, explains the history behind the allegations and discusses the significance of locs. “When you see someone with locs, we have committed to an aesthetic that celebrates the texture and plasticity of our hair. Pushing back against what? Western, Eurocentric ideas of beauty,” she said. (Meghan Tansey Whitton)

WARNING: The following includes graphic descriptions of violence carried out during and after the era of the transatlantic slave trade.

What significance do locs hold for Black individuals who choose to wear them?

Charmaine Nelson: For Black individuals, locs are not merely hair. When you see someone with locs, it represents a commitment to an aesthetic that honors the texture and versatility of our hair. It is a resistance against Western, Eurocentric beauty standards. Therefore, when we decide to grow our hair and style it in this distinct way, we are defying white racism while celebrating our own unique beauty.

For Rastas, wearing locs also involves a spiritual commitment. There’s a promise to never cut your locs, which represents a covenant with God and a spiritual practice. Thus, when police attack and forcibly cut locs from Black individuals, it is a profound violation of our bodily integrity and, for many, our spirituality.

What is the historical context of white individuals forcibly cutting Black hair?

Charmaine Nelson: Legally, [Black individuals] were considered chattel, or movable personal property. “We will strip them of their human status.” Brutality was a systematic physical assault on Black bodies treated as objects.

Historical records from white enslavers show that a common form of punishment was head shaving, forcibly cutting the hair of enslaved Black individuals. This often occurred when white women would shave the heads of Black women they deemed beautiful in front of their white husbands.

“I will shave your head to the scalp so that you lose control over how your body appears. That, too, is something I possess as your enslaver.”

Aly Ndiaye: During the transatlantic slave trade and the Middle Passage, individuals were shaved to strip away their identities. When they boarded the ships, they were shaved because intricate hairstyles were indicators of status and societal position. For every life stage, there was a corresponding hairstyle.

Aly Ndiaye, an independent historian, spoke with CBC News to break down Montreal police’s alleged actions and explain their connection to slavery and the history of racism in the province. (Philipe Ruel)

Moreover, due to racism, slavery, and colonialism, Black hair has often been viewed as unattractive and not conforming to Eurocentric beauty standards. As a result, individuals had their hair shaved or straightened, facing judgment based on their hairstyles, like Afros being deemed unprofessional or abnormal.

In the 1950s and 1960s, during the Black Power movement, many began embracing their Afros as a means of reclaiming identity. Hairstyles became a way to express one’s heritage and beauty, allowing individuals to reconnect with their African identity that had been stolen and dehumanized.

American revolutionary and educator Angela Davis sits with her head on her hand, shortly after she was fired from her post as philosophy professor at UCLA due to her membership of the Communist Party of America, 27th November 1969. Davis followed up her brilliant early academic career by joining the Black Panthers and being listed on the FBI Most Wanted list. She was acquitted of all charges and continues to be a writer, educator, and activist for race, class, and gender equality. (Photo by Hulton Archive/Getty Images)

The iconic Afro hairstyle of American activist and thinker Angela Davis has become a visual symbol of the Black Power movement. (Hulton Archive/Getty Images)

What is the origin of the racist practice of collecting Black hair as trophies?

Charmaine Nelson: Following slavery, there was an increase in lynching, particularly in the U.S. and other regions of the Americas. White mobs would gather and decide to kill a specific Black individual—often a man or boy—for entertainment. As photography emerged, these mobs began capturing images of their acts and turning them into postcards, which were mailed to others. After murdering a Black individual, they would typically burn the body and take souvenirs from it.

Aly Ndiaye: This practice served as a way to assert dominance and humiliate the victim. After lynchings, members of the mob would often fight over who could take a body part as a trophy—“Who gets a finger? Who gets a finger bone?” Some would even remove genitalia to keep as mementos. To this day, some families discover human bones in their ancestors’ possessions, remnants of these brutal acts.

WATCH | Residents protesting outside Montréal-Nord’s Station 39 in June:

Montréal-Nord residents rally outside local police station over racism allegations

June 15|

Duration

1:32

Montreal’s police chief announced Friday that 16 officers from Station 39 in Montréal-Nord are under investigation for alleged racist and hateful acts committed against Black and Arab people. Residents gathered outside the station on Monday evening to demand justice and change.

What has been the historical role of law enforcement in controlling and inflicting violence on Black individuals in Quebec?

Charmaine Nelson: The framework of policing in Western countries, particularly in the Americas, is rooted in slavery. Sheriffs in Montreal and Quebec City played significant roles in slavery; they were responsible for jails. If an enslaved person escaped, it was the sheriff’s duty to pursue and return them to their enslaver. Additionally, when someone went bankrupt, the sheriff managed their estate, which in the case of an enslaver, meant overseeing the enslaved individuals as part of settling debts. Law enforcement was deeply involved in maintaining the institution of slavery, protecting enslavers’ rights to continue exploiting individuals of African descent. Hence, Black people were criminalized and viewed as the hunted from the very beginning.

What insights does this history provide regarding the current allegations?

Aly Ndiaye: In the 21st century, when a police officer retains a loc from a Black individual who has experienced harassment, it resonates with the history of lynching and slavery. It reflects a racist assertion of superiority and a means to boast about such actions, perpetuating a culture of violence rather than bridging divides. This act is not isolated; it is inextricably linked to slavery, colonialism, and racism. Even if those officers do not consciously connect their actions to the history of slavery, the implications of their actions are steeped in a long legacy of violence and the oppressive history of policing Black lives. They often detach their actions from this historical context, trivializing the issue at hand. I am anxious to see the outcomes for those involved from Poste 39, but I harbor little expectation for meaningful consequences.

Tag: rewrite-pending

Source

Share

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *