It’s not every day that someone transitions from hosting a comedy night at their bar to improvising with an Emmy-winning comedian on the subway in New York City.
When Debbie Shields left to run some errands, she never anticipated she would engage in a conversation with comedian Conan O’Brien, but her sharp sense of humor ensured she was ready for the moment.
“If you throw it at me, I’ll throw it right back,” she shared with As It Happens host Nil Köksal.
Shields has gained internet fame following her interaction with O’Brien, which was featured on the latest episode of SubwayTakes.
O’Brien appeared as a guest on the widely-followed online talk show hosted by comedian Kareem Rahma, where everyday New Yorkers and celebrities comically share their controversial views during subway rides.
As the episode concluded, O’Brien expressed his apologies to Shields as she took a seat next to Rahma. They exchanged handshakes and dove into an impromptu scene, during which O’Brien humorously claimed they were previously married.
Shields quickly quipped that they had two children, remarking, “One’s in medical school, and the other is in jail,” which prompted laughter from the former late-night host.
Many viewers praised her quick wit and ability to match O’Brien’s comedic pace. He was equally impressed.
O’Brien mentioned to New York Magazine that he is interested in collaborating with Shields again. “I’d be willing to do a sitcom with her,” he said. “Or we could take our act on the road for a two-person show.”
Shields expressed to Köksal her enthusiasm for a future collaboration with him. Here’s a glimpse of their dialogue.
Debbie, what is your current relationship status with Conan O’Brien? Is remarriage a possibility? Did he leave you again?
He just completed his interview and exited the train. “Bye Debbie.”
How are the kids handling this situation?
They’re okay. They’re accustomed to him being absent.
But seriously, how are you coping with all this newfound attention?
It’s wild right now. I’ve been on SXM radio, featured in the New York Times, and on 1010 radio.
Are there international inquiries as well?
Yes, I received a call from Japan at 1:30 in the morning, and others from Australia and England. It’s been hectic.
Did you have any idea what to expect that day on the train?
Not at all. I was simply going to meet my accountant for my business.

O’Brien appeared thrilled with the unexpected encounter. (Emma McIntyre/Getty Images/SiriusXM)
Did you notice his distinctive orange hair and pale complexion? He often jokes about that himself, so I feel comfortable mentioning it.
No, I noticed a camera crew. When my friend said, “Oh, that’s Conan O’Brien,” I thought, “Okay.” But I was focused on finding a seat since I always look for one on the subway. I managed to grab a seat and told him, “You hold it, and I’m going to say hi.” And that was all it took.
Your comedic timing was impeccable. Have you always had that knack for humor?
Absolutely. If you give me something, I’ll give it back. That’s just how it works.
That’s the quintessential New Yorker in you, I’d say. But you take it to another level.
Thank you.
Despite how relaxed you seemed, were you nervous at all?
Not in the slightest; I was having a great time.
He seemed to enjoy it too.
Yes, we both had a wonderful time.
You were a fan of Conan before. What do you appreciate about his work?
Yes, I admire his comedic style. He’s clever, quick, and takes risks. I just really like him.
Were you familiar with the show SubwayTakes prior to this?
No, I had no knowledge of that show whatsoever.
It’s amazing when you connect with a celebrity you admire, and the interaction goes so well. After your encounter, when did you realize this was more than just a memorable moment for you?
On Tuesday evening. Someone mentioned, “Hey, you were on Conan, we saw it.” I was at my bar when people started showing me. Then Wednesday morning, it exploded. Calls were coming in at eight in the morning saying, “You’re all over the internet. You’ve got five million views.” Then by ten o’clock, someone called, “You’re on channel five, on channel four.” I was like, “Oh my God.” It felt surreal.
I do this with patrons at my bar, too. My bar is called Confessions Bar, and I host comedy nights on Fridays. I introduce the comics and interact with the audience, making jokes about their outfits and whatever else, and they all appreciate it. I love seeing people happy. If I were to rest my head tonight, I hope people would remember that I made them laugh.
Oh, they’re certainly going to remember, Debbie. Do you think Conan will drop by your bar?
He’s been in contact with me. Kareem’s team has reached out regarding another show with him.
What would be your dream show?
Saturday Night Live.
Conan could probably help make that happen. He mentioned wanting to do a sitcom with you.
Yes, and I would absolutely love to do that with him.
What does this experience teach you about life?
Life is humorous; you never know where your blessings will come from. That’s why it’s important to live your life in a positive manner. When the energy of God, or whatever you believe in, sees you doing your best and being genuine, blessings will come your way.
With the comedy night at Confessions, are you planning to weave this new chapter of your life and your ex-husband into your bar’s theme?
Yes, we created a drink called Baby Daddy O’Brien, made with whiskey, Triple Sec, lemon, lime, and blood orange.
Will you consider bringing your show to Toronto in the future?
That would be fantastic. I adore Toronto and Canada. I’ve visited Canada numerous times.
I’m sure people would love to see you take the subway here too, Debbie. Thank you for this conversation.
It’s my pleasure. Just remember to always laugh out loud.
That’s the secret to life.
Tag: rewrite-pending





