Canada’s highest court has determined that Elections Canada made a significant administrative blunder that could jeopardize the integrity of the electoral system when it neglected to resolve issues related to mail-in ballots in a Montreal-area riding prior to the 2025 federal election.
The Supreme Court of Canada annulled the election results for the Terrebonne riding in a ruling issued in February, with the rationale for its decision made public on Friday.
The court stated that its verdict to mandate a new election “bolsters public confidence in the electoral process by confirming that a federal election should not be influenced by recognized and rectifiable official mistakes,” as noted in the decision.
Liberal candidate Tatiana Auguste was initially declared the victor in the Terrebonne riding with a one-vote margin over incumbent Bloc Québécois candidate Nathalie Sinclair-Desgagné in April 2025.
The Bloc candidate contested the election results and sought a byelection after a Bloc supporter claimed that she had attempted to vote by mail using a special ballot that was never counted.
The concerned voter, Emmanuelle Bosse, reported that her special ballot was returned to her address due to an error in the postal code on a label provided by Elections Canada.
A Superior Court judge denied Sinclair-Desgagné’s appeal for a new election, but the Supreme Court overturned that ruling in a divided decision announced from the bench in February, leading to a byelection that Auguste won on April 13.
Justice Mahmud Jamal, writing for the majority, indicated that an Elections Canada employee had been aware for several weeks that some voters received envelopes with incorrect postal codes, yet the organization did not take measures to rectify the issue.
The ruling stated, “Elections Canada did not count or receive an elector’s vote because it took inadequate steps to address the error, despite being aware of its mistake and expecting that affected electors would be contacted by one of its representatives.”
“Elections Canada was responsible for the error and had both the ability and obligation to amend it.”
The court learned that an Elections Canada employee had distributed incorrectly addressed envelopes for mail-in ballots to approximately 40 voters.
He recognized his error more than three weeks prior to election day but failed to notify any supervisors. The employee felt the mistake did not appear to be problematic “since the Terrebonne polling station was receiving completed special ballots as usual, including those in envelopes with the postal code error,” the ruling noted.
Justice Jamal asserted that the Superior Court made an error in concluding that an inadvertent administrative mistake was not severe enough to be categorized as a voting irregularity.
“Unintentional, honest, or good faith errors can also compromise the integrity of the electoral process if they hinder electors from exercising their right to vote,” the judge stated.
Elections Canada issued a statement indicating that it reviewed its special ballot procedures following the election and has implemented changes. The agency mentioned it would thoroughly analyze the Supreme Court’s ruling before determining any further steps.
“Elections Canada continuously seeks new methods to better equip the thousands of workers who facilitate the execution of federal elections,” the agency added in its release.
-
Quebec Liberal leader criticizes decision to send voter guides in French only in letter to premier
-
PQ leader expresses concerns over potential federal interference in Quebec election
-
The Alberta NDP won Calgary’s byelection, but the electoral map may shift significantly in the next election
The ruling was decided by a 6-3 vote.
In a dissenting opinion, Justices Andromache Karakatsanis and Sheilah Martin stated that the clerical error did not rise to the level of seriousness required to warrant a new election.
They cautioned that this ruling could lead to an influx of future challenges.
“If this error, affecting just one vote, is sufficient to revisit an election outcome, it is difficult to determine what kind of mistake would not meet this threshold,” they noted. “Such a minimal threshold could jeopardize the validity of all election results, eroding the stability, certainty, and conclusiveness of electoral outcomes.”
Conversely, the majority maintained that the standards for overturning an election remain rigorous, asserting that the decision would not “open the floodgates” to electoral disputes stemming from every mistake made during an election.






