Skip to content

Canada’s Secret Plans to Support U.S. Invasion of Iraq Revealed

Lucas James Taylor 0 11 min read
Share

Canada, which notably opposed the Iraq war in 2003, was poised to support the U.S.-led invasion by deploying naval vessels for combat, contingent on a UN Security Council approval, as revealed by cabinet documents.

Records from the last cabinet meetings prior to the invasion indicate that the government was contemplating the scenario where the UN would authorize military intervention, reflecting the gravity of this potentiality on ministers as they deliberated moral considerations regarding life and death.

The invasion, initiated by the U.S., was ostensibly aimed at disarming Saddam Hussein of nonexistent weapons of mass destruction. The administration of U.S. President George W. Bush presented the conflict as a facet of the broader war on terror, which had commenced following the September 11 attacks nearly two years earlier.

On March 17, 2003, just days before the invasion commenced, Prime Minister Jean Chrétien formally declared in the House of Commons that Canada would not be part of the U.S.-led “coalition of the willing” in Iraq.

“If military action occurs without a new resolution from the Security Council, Canada will not take part,” Chrétien stated during question period, prompting a standing ovation from his supporters.

WATCH | Chrétien refuses to support U.S. war in Iraq:

When Chrétien refused to support U.S. war in Iraq

March 12|

Duration

1:31

In 2003, Jean Chretien stated firmly that, without the backing of the United Nations, Canada wouldn’t support the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq.

On that very day, the U.S. had pulled a resolution from the Security Council that would have explicitly permitted military action, as it appeared likely to be defeated.

CBC News acquired the minutes from the last cabinet meeting — dated February 25, 2003 — prior to Chrétien’s announcement through a request for information.

While the U.S.’s resolution encountered opposition before its introduction, the documents indicate that the Canadian government was preparing potential military responses.

John McCallum, the then minister of national defence, noted in the meeting that if the resolution passed, Canada would not be able to provide ground support at that time due to commitments in Afghanistan, but suggested that Ottawa could dispatch naval vessels.

“[McCallum] emphasized that the recent commitment to provide a peacekeeping contingent in Afghanistan would preclude Canada from deploying ground troops, yet other military assets, like warships, could be redirected from their current missions in the area if Canada opted to partake,” the minutes documented.

Retired general Raymond Henault, who served as chief of the defence staff in 2003, stated that the documents align with what he communicated to the government regarding the Canadian Armed Forces’ potential contributions to the Iraq conflict should Ottawa decide to engage.

A man in military fatigues speaks into a microphone.

Gen. Ray Henault, chief of defence staff, addresses troops in Kabul, Afghanistan, in 2004. (Stephen Thorne/The Canadian Press)

“We operated under the premise that we should remain prepared to respond to whatever the government decided, whether it was to involve or not involve,” Henault shared in an interview with CBC News.

At that time, Canadian vessels were positioned in the Persian Gulf conducting counterterrorism and anti-smuggling operations.

CBC News reported in 2011 that a U.S. diplomatic memo released by WikiLeaks indicated discussions between U.S. and Canadian officials regarding how those naval vessels could be utilized as the invasion commenced.

However, the cabinet minutes suggest that the vessels’ involvement in the broader war on terror could have been enhanced or “redeployed” if the UN authorized military action.

Henault indicated that such redeployment would mean the ships “would have participated in any naval combat operations in support of the Iraq invasion,” potentially including vessels equipped with patrol aircraft like helicopters. He also suggested that Canadian special forces might have been engaged.

CBC News did not receive a reply from a representative of Chrétien when inquiring whether the former prime minister would be willing to participate in an interview for this article.

WATCH | Chrétien reflects on Iraq war decision:

Chrétien reflects on decision to keep Canada out of Iraq war

March 19, 2023|

Duration

4:31

Rosemary Barton Live speaks with Canada’s former prime minister Jean Chrétien about his decision 20 years ago to keep Canada out of the war in Iraq.

Senator Percy Downe, who served as Chrétien’s chief of staff and attended the 2003 cabinet meeting, recalled that the government was following the military’s lead in planning for the possibility of Canada joining the conflict.

“I believe had we joined, we could have made a significant contribution. The downside was… hundreds of Canadian families and individuals would have faced the impact due to casualties,” Downe remarked to CBC News.

During the 2003 meeting, McCallum also contended that reallocating ground forces from Afghanistan to Iraq would impede Canada’s contributions to the “global war on terrorism.”

“He reminded ministers about the important challenge of maintaining security in Afghanistan, asserting that Canada’s involvement was a credible first-tier contribution to the global fight against terrorism and that withdrawing to engage in a war in Iraq would be detrimental to this effort,” the documents indicated.

At that time, Canadian personnel were in Afghanistan involved in Operation Apollo, and the government had just committed to Operation Athena, which commenced in the summer of 2003.

“Afghanistan was dominating all our efforts at that time,” Henault stated.

“We maintained that we couldn’t deploy ground forces in both locations. It simply wasn’t feasible, especially in the long run.”

Two men in suits sit down in front of a row of Canadian and American flags.

U.S. President George W. Bush reaches out to shake hands with Chrétien in Detroit in September 2002. Bush was making his case to the prime minister for a military campaign against Iraq. (Doug Mills/The Associated Press)

Though Canada was not a member of the Security Council at the time, Chrétien instructed his team to concentrate on facilitating the resolution of the deadlock as the council debated the U.S. resolution.

“[The prime minister] stressed that Canadian efforts were directed at bridging differing viewpoints within the Security Council to minimize the chance of a stalemate or unilateral action that could lead to a serious diminishment of the United Nations’ role and importance,” the minutes from the February 2003 meeting noted.

Following Chrétien’s remarks, then foreign affairs minister Bill Graham informed the cabinet that Canada would “persist in clearly conveying its objective of achieving disarmament in Iraq, rather than pursuing regime change, and that continuing to negotiate more broadly acceptable UN resolution language remained the most viable approach.”

Michael Kergin, who was Canada’s ambassador in Washington at the time, observed that from his standpoint, the Bush administration had already decided on invading Iraq and regarded the push for UN backing as an “irrelevant nuisance and chaff.”

“They regarded the activities in New York as completely inconsequential to their plans. They were not engaging much in the corridors. They were focused on their public messaging,” he remarked.

A question of sovereignty

Despite Ottawa’s official announcement being made mere days before the invasion, Kergin sensed that Washington had essentially excluded Canada from participation after Chrétien had informed Bush in an earlier meeting that the prime minister required “absolute proof” of Saddam’s stockpiling of weapons of mass destruction.

“The signals we were sending were sufficient for them to conclude, ‘Alright, we won’t involve you in the core planning and discussions about this,'” Kergin stated.

“The Americans never truly pressured us because they already understood.”

WATCH | George W. Bush defends Iraq invasion:

George W. Bush defends Iraq invasion

November 30, 2004|

Duration

1:05

During his visit to Canada, U.S. President George W. Bush speaks about American actions in Iraq.

Kergin mentioned that he had advised the government to inform the Americans ahead of any official announcement. However, he recalled that Chrétien’s team kept the information so confidential that even he was unaware of what was happening during the March 17 question period.

“I believe they were worried that if we informed the Americans first, there might be a leak in Washington and this could get out before the Canadians were informed,” Kergin noted.

“Without prior knowledge of that decision, I saw it on television — because I had a TV in my office, of course — during question period just like everyone else.”

Chrétien’s final decision to abstain from the conflict was interpreted as a demonstration of Canada’s sovereignty at that time.

However, Downe believed the government was merely following the precedent set by Prime Minister Lester B. Pearson, who opted out of the Vietnam War decades earlier.

“We had a history of independence in making our own choices,” he remarked.

“Prime Minister Chrétien, as you know, was well-versed in politics. He had extensive experience and understood the questions to pose and how to press the Americans for the information he required. They never truly did that.”

WATCH | CBC report from 2003 on the prospects of an American-led invasion of Iraq:

Will Americans support another war in Iraq?

January 21, 2003|

Duration

6:14

As the United States faces the prospect of another war against Iraq in 2003, CBC correspondent Joe Schlesinger explores the human tragedy of the 1991 Gulf War.

Overall, cabinet members seemed to endorse the prime minister’s choice, based on further documents that CBC News acquired through an access to information request.

“Ministers expressed their support for the stance and management of the Iraq issue,” indicated minutes from a cabinet meeting dated March 18, 2003, the day following Chrétien’s announcement.

“Ministers also acknowledged the necessity for ongoing principled leadership to aid in rebuilding Iraq after conflict, to foster greater stability in the Middle East, and to persist in Canadian efforts against terrorism.”

However, Downe noted there were apprehensions, even within the cabinet, that the decision might strain relations with the U.S.

“Reflecting on 25 years later, everyone is pleased that Prime Minister Chrétien made that choice, but at the time it was quite contentious,” he commented.

“There were individuals in cabinet, and within caucus — particularly in the business community across Canada — who were very concerned that not participating could significantly harm Canada.”

Protesters stand near a banner that reads "Peace on earth, not war in Iraq."

Activists with the Committee for Peace in Iraq deliver a message, a Christmas tree and sing carols in front of Chrétien’s official residence in Ottawa, Monday Dec. 23, 2002. (Fred Chartrand/The Canadian Press)

Kergin mentioned that he did not encounter significant backlash from the Bush administration itself, but he did receive calls from Republican members of Congress.

Although the U.S. and its allies initiated military operations without Security Council authorization, a 2020 research paper indicated that Canadian intelligence assessments regarding the situation in Iraq — including Baghdad’s weapons capabilities and the regional fallout from an invasion — were generally accurate leading up to the conflict.

The potential for regional instability seemed to concern Graham, who briefed the cabinet during the February 25 meeting about “efforts being made to advise Canadians in the Middle East of the growing dangers of remaining in the area.”

Other ministers also “expressed concern over the likelihood of a paradoxical situation where conflict in Iraq could amplify rather than mitigate terrorism; and that Canada should contemplate the long-term factors contributing to terrorism.”

The war ultimately resulted in a power vacuum that allowed ISIS to emerge as a credible threat in Iraq. Canada and its allies would deploy troops in 2014 in an effort to combat the militant group and prevent it from launching terrorist attacks against the West.

Debates on when taking life is ‘justified’

As the discussions about Iraq were concluding in the February 25 cabinet meeting, the overall conversation shifted towards philosophical matters, with ministers “debating the circumstances under which war, and ultimately taking life, is justified.”

The dialogue also touched upon issues that resonate with concerns in 2026, particularly the fractures among allies.

“Ministers articulated serious concerns regarding the emerging fault lines among North Atlantic allies and within Europe, as well as the implications of a decline in multilateralism,” the documents noted.

When reflecting on those final conversations from over two decades ago, Downe recalled it being “a highly charged, emotionally intense period.”

“The emotions were exceedingly high because a decision to engage in Iraq would likely result in Canadian casualties, devastating families, and leaving children without a parent,” he lamented.

“It’s an incredibly weighty decision to make.”

Mobile users: View the document
(PDF KB)
(Text KB)
CBC is not responsible for 3rd party content
Share
Author Lucas James Taylor

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *