WARNING: This article includes information regarding violence against children and attempted suicide.
On Thursday, Lindsay Clancy’s attorney requested that the judge overseeing the Massachusetts woman’s murder trial find her not guilty by reason of insanity, asserting that the prosecution had not demonstrated that she understood the wrongfulness of killing her three young children due to her mental illness.
Defense lawyer Kevin Reddington made this plea to Judge William Sullivan just six days after the trial concluded in a stalemate, while a fourth juror from the 12-member panel publicly shared that a single juror had obstructed their ability to reach a unanimous verdict.
The jury in Plymouth, Massachusetts, deliberated for a week before Sullivan declared a mistrial on August 4, following multiple notifications from the jury that they were deadlocked.
Prosecutors have not yet indicated whether they intend to retry Clancy. However, Reddington contended that the judge should independently resolve the issue, arguing that the prosecution did not provide sufficient evidence during the six-week trial for a jury to convict Clancy of the first-degree murder charges she faces.
Reddington pointed out that even the expert witnesses for the prosecution acknowledged that Clancy was grappling with a significant mental illness at the time of the incident. He noted that the evidence merely indicated that she was capable of performing familiar tasks, but did not demonstrate that she could comprehend the immorality of her actions.
“No rational jury could conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that she did not have a mental illness or defense when the Commonwealth’s own evidence established that she did,” Reddington stated in his motion, referring to the prosecution.
He requested that the judge consider his motion during a hearing set for September 29. A representative for Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz did not respond to a request for comment.
Clancy, 36, has confessed to strangling her three children with exercise bands on January 24, 2023, in the basement of their home located in the Boston suburb of Duxbury. Subsequently, she inflicted wounds on herself with a knife and jumped from a second-floor window, resulting in her paralysis.
Holdout ‘wouldn’t engage’ with other members: juror
During the trial, Reddington worked to persuade jurors that she should be deemed not guilty by reason of insanity, referred to in Massachusetts as lack of criminal responsibility, claiming she experienced postpartum psychosis at the time of the killings of Cora, 5; Dawson, 3; and eight-month-old Callan.
In his motion, Reddington mentioned that 11 out of the 12 jurors were inclined to find her not guilty due to lack of criminal responsibility but were unable to reach a verdict because of one juror who, despite recognizing reasonable doubt, refused to agree to a not guilty verdict for Clancy.
-
Will Lindsay Clancy face a new trial? What’s next after mistrial declared
-
Lindsay Clancy’s ex-husband threatens legal action over ‘relentless’ conspiracy theories
One juror, Nick Dargie, shared in an interview with ABC’s Good Morning America that aired on Thursday that the juror who held out often “wouldn’t engage” with the other jury members.
“I believe that if they retried the case in the same manner, nine times out of ten, a jury would return with not guilty by reason of insanity,” Dargie stated. “There’s no doubt in my mind.”
If you or someone you know is in distress, here are resources for help:
- Canada’s Suicide Crisis Helpline: Call or text 988.
- Provincial and territorial mental health support.
- Kids Help Phone: 1-800-668-6868. Text 686868. Live chat counselling on the website.
- This guide from the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health provides advice on how to approach conversations about suicide with those you are concerned about.
Tag: rewrite-pending






