Skip to content

SETI Institute Unveils Game Theory Approach to Search for Alien Signals

Lucas James Taylor 0 8 min read
Share

Being the sole voice in the universe can feel quite isolating.

For those unaware, the quest to find life — especially intelligent life — has persisted for many years. Yet, thus far, it appears that we are alone.

Astronomers pursue the search for life through two main approaches: they seek biosignatures, which are indicators of historical or present biological activity (consider the Mars rovers), and technosignatures, which signify technology from intelligent beings. The latter primarily relies on radio astronomy rather than optical methods, as any technological activity would be occurring at vast distances beyond our visual reach. Essentially, astronomers are tuning in to listen for signals.

One leading organization in this pursuit has been the SETI Institute. Established in 1984, it has been diligently scanning the skies for radio emissions that might be attempting to reach out to us humble inhabitants of Earth. While the organization has focused on star systems that host known exoplanets, no extraterrestrial signals have been found to date.

Recently, researchers at this Mountain View, California-based institute developed an innovative technique to search for these signals, utilizing principles from game theory. This new strategy not only identifies where to search for signals but also when.

Game theory is a mathematical discipline that examines decision-making processes among interacting entities, where each participant’s choices depend on the other’s strategy, often without knowledge of the other’s actions. The outcome is determined by the combined strategies of both parties.

WATCH | Game theory explained:

In the case of the SETI Institute, they are employing the concept of the “Schelling point” from game theory. A frequently cited illustration by economist Thomas Schelling is this: Picture yourself arranging a meeting in New York City without specifying a time or location. Both individuals might independently opt to meet at Grand Central Terminal at noon, as it is a well-known gathering venue and a sensible time for a rendezvous.

Now, consider this in the context of detecting an alien civilization, focusing on the anti-solar point, which is a theoretical location in the celestial sphere directly opposite the sun (180 degrees away). Imagine a line extending from the sun through Earth out into the cosmos.

What if there existed an alien society capable of observing Earth as it transits in front of the sun? What if they were aware of a planet orbiting our star and directed a signal towards us?

We possess the location — Earth — and the timing — during a transit.

In essence, we are convening at Grand Central at noon.

Voices in the void

This anti-solar approach was proposed years ago, but adequate funding was lacking until now.

“I reflected on these concepts that have been circulating in academic literature for quite some time,” stated Sophia Sheikh, a technosignature research scientist at the SETI Institute and the lead author of the study. “Finally, the anti-solar point concept is getting its moment in the spotlight.”

In a recent publication issued on November 3, astronomers from the SETI Institute revealed that they recorded 1.9 million radio signals utilizing this technique. However, after filtering the signals, none were identified as originating from extraterrestrial technology — all were terrestrial in nature. It appears that we humans, with our satellites and radio broadcasts, create quite a racket.

The research excluded that specific region of the sky — yet this does not imply that there is nothing beyond. The universe is vast.

The team intends to persist with this method for at least four years, according to Sophia Sheikh, who is also the lead author of the paper.

An illustration of the Milky Way galaxy with a small circle near.

The Sun and our solar system in relation to the Milky Way galaxy. The white circle indicates the area where the majority of exoplanets have been found with current telescopes. (NASA/JPL-Caltech/T. Pyle)

They are specifically searching for what is referred to as a narrowband signal, described by Sheikh as a “‘we are here’ … akin to an air horn, in the radio frequencies.”

“This signal might contain information, or it could be what we term a carrier wave. So, the air horn indicates, ‘Hey, there’s something noteworthy here.’”

However, don’t envision astronomers listening intently with headphones, reminiscent of Ellie Arroway from the 1997 film Contact. Instead, sophisticated computer algorithms analyze the data.

The SETI Institute employs the Allen Telescope Array, which consists of 42 adjustable 6.1-meter diameter telescopes located at the Hat Creek Radio Observatory in California. This array has been utilized to search for extraterrestrial signals since the 1980s.

A set of five large telescopes point up at the sky

Displayed here is the Allen Telescope Array, the first radio telescope designed specifically to search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI). Situated at the Hat Creek Radio Observatory in northern California, it includes 42 antennas. (Simon Steel)

Science fiction?

The endeavor to find signals from extraterrestrial sources may seem like something from a science fiction narrative. Yet, our Milky Way galaxy is estimated to contain over 100 billion stars, fostering the belief that there should be life beyond Earth, particularly with the knowledge that most stars have at least one exoplanet.

Additionally, the Drake equation, formulated by American astrophysicist Frank Drake in 1961, was designed to estimate the number of civilizations capable of communication in the Milky Way.

The outcome depends on numerous unknown factors, but it is not zero.

Adam Frank, a professor of astrophysics at the University of Rochester in New York, is also investigating technosignatures. He received NASA’s inaugural grant to explore non-radio technosignatures, focusing instead on chemical signatures or other markers of intelligent life.

He has commented on the past perception of the search for extraterrestrial intelligence.

“The giggle factor, which has lingered throughout much of my career, has dissipated,” Frank noted, reflecting on how the search was not taken seriously in earlier decades. “It never made sense.”

This is particularly true following the initial detection of exoplanets in 1992 and the subsequent discovery of the first exoplanet orbiting a sun-like star in 1995.

In the event of a detection…

What would happen if a signal were detected?

Surprisingly, there are established protocols from the International Academy of Astronautics. Besides the essential task of confirming and validating the discovery, a significant directive is: Do not respond. (If you’ve read or viewed 3 Body Problem by Liu Cixin, you’ll grasp why this might be prudent.)

In reality, this isn’t a major concern. Signals will traverse light-years of distance. For instance, if we receive a signal from a star system located 100 light-years away, and we on Earth decide to send a reply, it would take 100 years for our message to reach the extraterrestrial civilization, and another 100 years to receive their response. That adds up to 300 years just to convey a simple “Hello.”

“Communication is not the top priority,” Frank remarked.

Frank’s investigations focus on searching for evidence of technosignatures through examining the chemistry of exoplanets.

“For instance, we can analyze the atmospheres of distant planets for substances like chlorofluorocarbons … a chemical exclusively produced by industrial activities,” he explained. “Such substances would never be found solely in nature, within a biosphere.”

Ultimately, it may be more about finding solace in the knowledge that we are not alone.

This image shows the printout of a strong signal received at the Big Ear Radio Observatory in 1977. Astronomer Jerry Ehman circled the unusual signal and wrote, ‘Wow!’ in the margin. (Big Ear Radio Observatory and North American Astrophysical Observatory)

While we have yet to identify a conclusive radio signal that could suggest the existence of an alien civilization, there was the notable “Wow! Signal.” This intense radio transmission was detected in 1977 by the Big Ear telescope in Ohio, lasting for 72 seconds but was never observed again. Since that time, some theories have emerged suggesting that it may have been caused by passing comets.

So, when might we identify a signal from an alien source?

“I like to say,” Sheikh shared, “I hope that by the conclusion of my career, we will have insight into whether any radio signals in the galaxy are produced by other technologically advanced civilizations.”

Share

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *