Skip to content

Couple Faces Year-Long Separation Amid Citizenship Application Delays

Lucas James Taylor 0 7 min read
Share

One year ago, when Michel Pottier and his wife opted to relocate from Maine to Halifax, Pottier’s hometown, they aimed to prepare thoroughly and adhere to regulations.

Pottier arranged to transfer his employment to Canada, while his wife, Lindsey Jade Higgins, who is originally from the United States, submitted an application for spousal permanent resident status.

Initially, they believed the process would take merely a few months. However, after a year, Pottier has had to start working in Halifax while his wife remains in Portland, Maine, still awaiting her status.

Recently, Pottier discovered that they may face an additional year of separation in Canada — a consequence of the federal government’s implementation of changes to citizenship legislation, Bill C-3, which was enacted by Parliament late last year.

“We can’t be together,” expressed a frustrated Pottier. “It’s a tough situation to accept — especially since she’s so close.… But with the bureaucracy, you might as well be on another planet.”

According to CBC News, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada has quietly placed permanent resident applications on hold for an unspecified number of individuals who could now be eligible for citizenship under Bill C-3. This legislation allows those who can demonstrate a Canadian ancestry to qualify for Canadian citizenship.

As a result, those impacted find themselves in a state of uncertainty — lacking permanent resident status and caught in a nearly three-year backlog of citizenship certificate applications.

Pottier and his wife submitted her application for spousal family class sponsorship in September 2025. However, while tracing her ancestry for that application, they discovered that she had a Canadian great-grandmother, making her eligible for Canadian citizenship by descent as well.

They also applied for this citizenship in October 2025, during an interim program that permitted applications prior to the formal implementation of the “lost Canadians” legislation.

However, they were unaware that this additional application would lead to the current predicament they are facing.

Initially, the IRCC processed her permanent residence application without issues, including requiring her to pay for medical examinations in January. But a few days ago, Pottier was informed through the office of his MP, Justice Minister Sean Fraser, that his wife’s permanent resident application had been paused in September 2026 due to her potential eligibility for citizenship.

“Had we not submitted the proof of citizenship application, she would have received her PR by now,” Pottier remarked. “We believed we were making the right choice, but [we] inadvertently ruined any chance of starting our life together in Canada within a reasonable timeframe.”

Pottier mentioned that he and his wife are now reconsidering their aspiration to live in Canada.

Briannah Dale, a senior communications adviser for IRCC, explained that according to the department’s policies, it is not permissible to hold both permanent resident and Canadian citizen status simultaneously.

“If an individual applies for proof of citizenship while also seeking permanent residence, their permanent residence application will be suspended until the citizenship application is evaluated,” she stated in an email response.

“If citizenship is granted, the permanent residence application will be considered withdrawn. If citizenship is denied, the permanent residence application will revert to its original place in the processing queue and continue from there.”

Dale added that an IRCC officer might also pause a permanent residence application even if citizenship has not been applied for, should the officer have “compelling reasons to suspect that an applicant may already be a citizen under Canadian law.”

Dale noted that due to “systems limitations,” the department is unable to disclose the number of permanent residence applications that have been placed on hold because applicants may also qualify for citizenship.

However, she did mention that individuals who currently possess permanent resident status will not lose it while awaiting their citizenship certificate.

The processing time for those who submit applications today for family sponsorship of spouses outside of Canada (excluding Quebec) like Pottier’s wife is 18 months. Conversely, the wait for citizenship certificate applications has now escalated to 34 months, partly due to the influx of applications following the adoption of Bill C-3, especially from American applicants.

From December 15, 2025, when Bill C-3 was implemented, until August 31, IRCC has approved 7,900 applications for Canadian citizenship certificates under the new law. Additionally, another 22,570 individuals born abroad to a Canadian parent have also received citizenship certificates.

A Canadian citizenship certificate enables the holder to acquire a Canadian passport and reside and work in Canada. However, certain benefits, such as universal health care, have residency prerequisites.

The surge in demand for Canadian citizenship by descent has overwhelmed archives in both Canada and the U.S., inundating them with requests for birth certificates and other documents to establish Canadian ancestry, with some applicants tracing their lineage back several generations.

In early October, the Association of Canadian Archivists reached out to Immigration Minister Lena Metlege Diab, urging the federal government to provide financial support and resources to assist archives in managing the increased workload resulting from Bill C-3.

As of now, the association has not received a reply.

Montreal immigration attorney Lisa Middlemiss stated that Pottier’s family is not alone in their struggle with IRCC’s handling of permanent residence status and Bill C-3.

“This scenario occurs more frequently than one might believe,” she noted.

“We often consult with individuals who may have a potential claim to Canadian citizenship and have recently learned about Bill C-3, yet they also qualify or would typically qualify for permanent residency.”

Middlemiss mentioned that IRCC has yet to issue any guidance to immigration attorneys on “how to navigate this ambiguous situation.”

“The challenge is that individuals find themselves in a sort of processing limbo, where they are waiting for a permanent residence application to be processed, which may not occur if they are a Canadian citizen, and they are also uncertain whether their citizenship application will be expedited.”

WATCH | Certificate wait times surge:

Citizenship certificate wait times soar to nearly 3 years: IRCC

October 5|

Duration

1:59

Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada is struggling to handle a flood of citizenship applications. According to the department’s most recent update, those applying for a citizenship certificate could now face a wait of 33 months.

NDP immigration critic Jenny Kwan remarked that the implications of Bill C-3 on permanent resident status were not considered by Parliament during the legislation’s discussions.

Kwan has been attempting, without success, to obtain clarity from Diab’s office on behalf of a constituent caught in this predicament.

“I simply cannot comprehend why it is so challenging for the minister to perform her duties and provide that clarity and confirmation for the public and for us as MPs representing our constituents,” she stated.

“I believe the minister is falling short in her responsibilities regarding the implementation of Bill C-3.”

As of now, Diab’s office has not responded to inquiries from CBC News.

Share

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *