Skip to content

Carney Warns Canadians: Trade Shift from U.S. Will Come at a Cost

Lucas James Taylor 0 5 min read
Share

Prime Minister Mark Carney has cautioned Canadians that the nation’s shift away from the United States will incur expenses, yet he maintains that the alternative would be even more detrimental.

In a video shared on Tuesday, just hours after Canada implemented retaliatory tariffs, Carney reaffirmed the country’s strategy to counter the U.S. trade conflict by establishing new trade agreements with other nations to lessen dependence on the U.S.

“We possess everything necessary to pivot and thrive,” Carney stated. “This shift will come at a price. There is always a cost associated with action. However, it is nowhere near the cost of inaction.”

This video is part of a series Carney initiated last spring to keep Canadians informed about governmental policies and responses to U.S. trade measures.

Carney emphasized that the aim of these policies is to emerge stronger and more resilient so that “no nation can ever hold us hostage, allowing us to live as we choose.”

During his video message, Carney again accused the U.S. of attempting to impose regulations that would limit Canada’s ability to engage in trade with other nations and to foster and protect the French language and culture.

WATCH | Carney states U.S. aimed for ‘dependency’ in numerous areas:

Carney releases video saying U.S. wanted ‘dependency’ in too many areas

September 8|

Duration

1:48

In a segment from a 15-minute explanatory video released by Prime Minister Mark Carney’s office on Tuesday, Carney states that U.S. trade negotiators sought to make Canada ‘even more dependent on them, not less.’

Over the weekend, federal Conservatives reiterated their demand for Carney to disclose the full details of the agreement Canada opted out of, and for the government to reconvene Parliament before the scheduled return on September 21.

“We are urging the prime minister to be transparent. We understand that negotiating with the U.S. president is challenging. However, the best way to maintain unity and ensure everyone is aligned is to be candid about the costs, decisions, and the path ahead,” Poilievre remarked at a press conference in Regina on Monday.

“The only individuals who have not seen [the deal] are the Canadian citizens. They deserve access to it, so they can evaluate what we are advocating for and what we are opposing.”

‘Attempting to dismantle us’

In his video message, Carney indicated that Trump’s tariffs were intended to inflict greater harm on certain Canadians compared to others. The U.S. has persistently targeted Canada’s steel, aluminum, automobile, and lumber industries, primarily affecting workers in Ontario, Quebec, and British Columbia, while those in provinces like Alberta and Saskatchewan have felt less impact.

“Last spring, I cautioned that America is attempting to dismantle us so they can dominate us. I vowed that this will never, ever occur,” Carney declared in his video address.

Trump has openly speculated for nearly two years about the possibility of making Canada a U.S. state and has frequently referred to the prime minister as “governor.”

In January 2025, prior to taking his oath for a second term, Trump dismissed the use of military intervention to annex Canada, but mentioned he might consider employing “economic pressure” to integrate Canada into the U.S.

WATCH | The potential costs of counter-tariffs to Canadians:

What counter-tariffs could cost Canadians

September 7|

Duration

5:41

The trade conflict with the U.S. is set to escalate as Canada enacts dollar-for-dollar tariffs. CBC’s Eli Glasner analyzes the anticipated impact of the new levies on Canadian consumers.

Canada’s reciprocal tariffs became effective on Tuesday in retaliation to Trump’s latest imposition of 50 percent tariffs last month, which affected various products, including honey, hockey sticks, milk, and cheese.

Canada’s tariffs, which range from 15 to 50 percent, target solely those products listed by the U.S., matching the export dollar value of $27.8 billion.

“I do not advocate for escalating the conflict, as that is unproductive,” Carney stated in his video address.

“However, our tariffs are essential to safeguard our workers, protect our businesses, and support our communities. We cannot allow American products into Canada without tariffs while they impose fees on our companies to export to them.”

Carney also provided a historical perspective in his video message. He referenced the Benjamin Harrison administration in 1890 and the efforts to impose tariffs on Canada driven by Ohio congressman William McKinley, who later became president.

“It imposed 50 percent tariffs on our exports to the U.S. Does that sound familiar?” Carney asked.

“McKinley’s 50 percent tariff aimed to coerce us into dependence and ultimately annexation by the United States. In reality, it produced the opposite effect.

“Instead of weakening, Canada grew stronger. Rather than increasing our dependence, we diversified by altering our trading partners. Concurrently, inflation surged in the United States, leading to a financial crisis and a four-year economic depression.”

Share
Author Lucas James Taylor

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *